1996 Monte Bello Fares Well in Blind Tasting “Face-Off”

Wine Spectator


On 7 June 2016, Wine Spectator magazine published an article by writer Matt Kramer titled “Are You Really A Critic?” Here’s an excerpt from the article where he mentions the success that the 1996 Monte Bello had against some pretty stiff competition:

All 10 wines in the tasting came from the hotel’s 25,000-bottle cellar, and the wines were in pristine condition. With 20-year-old wines this is worth noting, as such impeccable provenance is rare these days.

Let me cut to the chase: Château Latour 1996 was the group’s sixth-ranked wine, which caused comment as you might expect. (It was my last-ranked wine.) The Château Margaux 1996 came in third. (I ranked it first.) Obviously, these are very big names.

The group’s first-place choice was Ridge Monte Bello Cabernet Sauvignon 1996 (it was my No. 2 wine), followed by Joseph Phelps Insignia 1996 (No. 3 for me).

Read the full article at WineSpectator.com (may require subscription)


In order to qualify for user related discounts, you must log in before proceeding with checkout. Click the button below to log in and receive these benefits, or close the window to continue.

Log In